In-Depth Articles Offer High-Authority Results, but Lack Relevance

Posted on Tuesday, November 26th, 2013 by Print This Post Print This Post

Categories - Featured, SEO

How Is This Relevant

In August, Google launched a new SERP feature called in-depth articles which feature long-form content about broad search terms.  Currently, this block of results appears at the bottom of the SERP and consists of three results, each with an image, title, publisher, and description.  In order to give content a chance to appear in this section, Google advises implementing markup, authorship and publisher markup, pagination and canonicalization, and First Click Free for restricted content.

In the brief time that in-depth articles have started appearing, it appears that Google’s algorithm heavily favors authority signals when serving in-depth results.  Some publishers that frequently appear include The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and Huffington Post.  One question that remains, however, is what purpose these results are serving.  After a few quick searches, in-depth articles appear to miss the mark in providing results that match user intent.  Take for example a basic search for the word “candy.”  Below are the in-depth articles that Google serves:

indepth candy

A user interested in “candy” might be looking for a broad definition or a historical background.  Instead, they get an interview with Ryan Gosling, a restaurant review for a place called Dirt Candy, and an article about a cheat to use in the game Candy Crush.  Not a single result is actually about the confections known as candy!  Because all the results are from highly authoritative publishers, each article is likely to be well-researched and well-written, but none of this matters because none of the results are relevant.  This lack of relevant results isn’t exclusive to “candy.”  Take as another example a search for “jazz.”

indepth jazz

The first result might be relevant, but the second two are most likely not.  One is a personal essay and the other is a highly specific article about one group’s historical hatred of jazz. It’s unlikely that users who entered the extremely broad query “jazz” were looking for any of these results – the Wikipedia article at the top of the SERP, which provides broad information, would likely satisfy their search intent before they reach the bottom of the page.  However, Google appears to be specifically targeting broad terms when serving in-depth article results.  These queries aren’t reserved to single word queries, as demonstrated by Moz’s analysis on in-depth articles, but these broad queries require the search engine to make wild guesses about a user’s intent.

In-depth articles served for broad term search queries, such as “fish” generally have vastly different kinds of results featuring specific pieces published across a wide range of dates.  In the example below, the search results provide users with fish-related articles ranging in focus from economics to neuroscience to ecology.

indepth fish

There doesn’t appear to be any underlying theme connecting the various topics represented in the in-depth results.  Instead, Google seems to be carpet bombing users with a wide variety of long-form content, hoping to capture their intent based on an otherwise unclear search query.

What’s more compelling is that the in-depth results that appear for each given query appear to remain constant no matter how many times a user performs the same search.  Searching for “fish” provides users with the same three results in the same order every time the search is performed. It will be interesting to see if Google starts to swap in-depth article results as they learn more about the user and are better able to serve results that satisfy individual search intent.

At this point, however, the algorithm for in-depth articles appears to put too much weight on the prestige of the publication at the expense of the article’s topical relevance.  In a sense, Google is attempting to use authority signals as a proxy for both high quality and relevant content.  They may have nailed the high quality aspect, but relevance may be harder to achieve.  At present, it seems a little too ambitious.  It would be interesting to see what sort of click-through rate these results are getting on the SERP to determine if users are actually responding to these results.  Until then, it’s difficult to ascertain what sort of explicit SEO value the in-depth results have for brands and marketers who are not writing for major publishers.

Tags | , , , , , , , , , ,

14 Responses to “In-Depth Articles Offer High-Authority Results, but Lack Relevance”

  1. There are digital cameras, X-ray machines and monitors which are facilitating the worldwide patients
    because of its world class dental services.

    They should encourage periodic appointments for routine teeth cleaning.
    Maybe your boss has taken away some of your responsibilities that you worked long
    and hard to earn, and then they turn around and hand some of them over to this new employee that seems to have fallen into
    the boss’ favor.

  2. Franziska says:

    Nowadays, computer system observer end up being driven a wedge between in CRT furthermore LCD screen. CRT observe is there built with a CRT
    television look along with be of the opinion reminiscent from the TELEVISION.
    The most important hindrances range from the importance in addition to
    extent. In recent times, was there close to forced
    outside the consumed (except in a few zastosowanimi with the aim of still job better) regarding LCD keep track
    of, and that is specified for that fluid ravenscroft panel, which often put back
    the been aware of CRT depiction pipe. The purchase price for the less important dimensions
    of the tool can often be cut image eminence.

  3. I’m extremely pleased to discover this great site.
    I want to to than you ffor obes time due tto this wonderful read!!
    I definitely enjoyed every partt oof itt and i also have you book-marked to check out
    new information in your web site.

    my homepage :: weber grill sale

  4. s5pv210 says:

    I blog quite often and I truly appreciate your content.
    This great article has really peaked my interest. I’m going to book mark your website and keep checking for new information about once per week.
    I opted in for your Feed too.

  5. Adell says:

    I constantly spent my half an hour to read this blog’s
    articles everyday along with a cup of coffee.

    My blog: Women Weight Loss Program (Adell)

  6. I like the helpful info you provide on your
    articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again right
    here regularly. I’m slightly certain I will learn plenty
    of new stuff right right here! Good luck for the following!

  7. On the physical plane, the hands are naturally the instruments of
    that will and divine blessing and have comme to symbolize Man, or Adam; for
    only beings on the evolutionary level off man are given the prerogative to
    determine their own fate. Most native experience delay in marriage when Rahu and Saturn are together stay in first, third
    or eleenth house from the Ascenant or the Moon sign. The primary
    benefit, of course, is that because you are having
    fun in your workout, you don’t get exhausted quite as
    quickly and you can sustain youjr activity level longer.

  8. Your style is unique in comparison to other people I have read stuff from.
    I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I’ll just bookmark
    this page.

  9. Sherryl says:

    certainly like your web-site but you have to take a look at the spelling on quite a few of your posts.
    A number of them are rife with spelling issues
    and I find it very bothersome to inform the truth nevertheless I will definitely come again again.

  10. Roxanne says:

    Hey there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers?
    My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing a few months of hard
    work due to no data backup. Do you have any methods to prevent hackers?

  11. מזונות says:

    Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed!
    Extremely helpful info specially the last phase :) I handle such
    info a lot. I was looking for this particular information for a
    long time. Thanks and best of luck.


  1. Best SEO, Content, and Social Media: Nov 2013 | ASEOHosting

Leave a Reply

Follow Us on Twitter